You wish your employees were more engaged, so you get ready to conduct another employee engagement survey.
Don’t do it.
At least, don’t do it before answering the questions below.
If you conduct another employee engagement survey without considering the following questions, you will be part of the dismal history of employee engagement improvement attempts.
Despite all that has been written about employee engagement and the millions of dollars spent on improving it, engagement levels still remain dismally low around the globe, according to the Gallup State of the American Workplace report:
While the state of the U.S. economy has changed substantially since 2000, the state of the American workplace has not. Currently, 30 percent of the U.S. workforce is engaged in their work, and the ratio of engaged to actively disengaged employees is roughly 2-to-1, meaning that the vast majority of U.S. workers (70 percent) are not reaching their full potential.”
If you’ve conducted engagement surveys in the past and seen the needle barely move over the years, you know the frustration many employers feel about this topic.
So how can you avoid being yet another employee engagement casualty? The first step is to make sure you can answer the following questions with a confident “Yes.”
For those you cannot, know that until you get that area right, your efforts to improve engagement will likely fail. Not only will you be unlikely to improve engagement, you could actually make it worse.
If not, don’t bother with a survey. Don’t ask about something that won’t change or that you don’t intend to work on regardless of the answer you get.
While this is so common sense, the basic tenet continues to get violated.
Making this mistake will make things worse. As you have undoubtedly experienced, when employee feedback is solicited and nothing is ever done with it, employees become even more disengaged and cynical about leadership’s sincerity. When lack of follow through is a part of a larger pattern of ignoring employee input—especially when it is requested — Learned Helplessness is fostered.
Learned Helplessness is where people believe “Nothing I do matters” so they become passive and apathetic. They don’t try to solve problems or show initiative, because they’ve learned that ”Nothing I do matters…so why even try.”
Thus, make sure you commit from the outset that you will DO something significant with your findings.
I know employers who had the results from their survey and sat on them for months. At the same time employees are wondering, “Ah…what happened to that survey? Are they going to do anything with it?”
Over time, this leads to an accumulation of negative thoughts and feelings towards their employer. When they finally do get the results, those accumulated perceptions and emotions don’t disappear. They continue on in the background, influencing how employees think and feel about leadership’s future decisions and communications.
Seeing the results late (or not at all) leads to the feeling that “They don’t care, so why should I?”
Don’t just report the statistical results. Share what they mean to you. Share your concerns about the areas that need improvement, and why you are concerned about those.
Also, communicate why you care about improving engagement — why it’s a win/win/win. Tell employees what you will be working on right away, what is going to be addressed down the road, and what won’t be changed…and why.
Even when employees have the chance to write in comments, survey results cannot provide the in-depth insights that individual interviews can. Because they allow for follow-up questions, individual interviews help you learn the “back story” about why employees responded as they did.
So for instance, why do they believe their input doesn’t matter? What happens at an organizational level for them to believe this?
What does their manager do — and not do — for them to believe this? What specifically could the organization do, and what could their manager do, that would make them feel their input mattered?
Asking employees follow-up questions can also bring to light specific examples of both good and bad practices that can been be used in management development training. They also provide important insights into the impact of specific leadership practices.
They enable the interviewer to explore the influence these have on how such situations influence how employees feel about their organization and manager and how such situations and practices affect the level of respect and trust employees have in their leaders.
While we all know that managers are the key to employee engagement, many employers still don’t invest in helping their managers perform their critical engagement role.
Are you?
Are you providing training and coaching for managers that help them master the behaviors and skills that lead to optimal employee engagement and achieve your business goals?
Does each manager’s own supervisor work with them on an ongoing basis to make sure they stay focused on cultivating these skills and engaging in these practices?
Does each manager have their own employee engagement-boosting professional development plan that provides focus and structure to these conversations? Also, are you making coaching available to your managers? Management training without coaching yields minimal results.
Finally, are you truly holding managers accountable for both their engagement scores and their professional development commitments? How are you doing this?
Most managers do not know how to customize the way they manage to the “unique recipe” of engagement drivers of each employee. This shortcoming is second only to employers not doing anything with survey data as the reason why employee engagement efforts have failed so miserably.
Employee engagement is an individual experience, not aggregated data resulting in a statistical data point.
If an employee’s unique “engagement recipe” of drivers and the manager’s way of managing this employee are not matched, it doesn’t matter what her department or overall organization’s engagement scores are.
She will not be as engaged or productive as she could be.
Gathering employee-specific engagement data also allows the employee and their manager to work together in a more collaborative, mutually accountable way to help the employee perform at their best.
So, before you do another engagement survey, ask yourself, Are we considering the fundamentals that will make this a success?
Tools to help managers engage employees in these customizing conversations can be found in: